On 24 October 1611, another Franciscan Fray Francisco de Dan Antonio ventured into Baler. He was the first Parish Priest assigned to Baler and pioneered the construction of the first Catholic Church. After five years as pastor, he was transferred to Pililia, Laguna on 31 March 1616. He died in Pila, Laguna on 6 February 1624, and was succeeded by Fray Miguel Soriano, et. al.
On 1 September 1658, due to the shortages of the Franciscan Missionaries, Fray Francisco de River, OFM, turned over the parish of Baler to the Recollects Order, under Padre Augustin de Santa Monica, AR. The last Franciscan administrator of the Baler parish before taken over by the Augustinian Recollects.
On 7 May 1703, the Franciscan reclaimed their foothold on Baler; and, in like manner, it was handed over by Padre Francisco de la Madre de Dios, AR, to Fray Juan de la Torre, OFM. Since then, Baler remained under the Franciscans until June 2, 1899, when finally the Spanish Garrison under the command of Lt. Saturnino Martin Cerezo surrendered to the Filipinos commanded by Col. Simeon Tecson.